Allowing Others to Find Their Own Way
I've always considered myself a helpful person - some may even call me a "fixer." I often see situations where I believe I know the right solution or the best course of action for someone, and I have the tendency to share my advice unsolicited. While my intentions are good, I've learned over time that constantly telling others what to do, even when meant constructively, can be more harmful than beneficial.
This realization first hit me a few years ago with my sister. She had been working an unsatisfying job for years, often coming home drained and unhappy. I continually urged her to make a career change or go back to school, convinced that I was steering her toward a better path. But the more I pressed and prodded, the more she resisted. My persistence only led her to shut down, avoid my calls, and ultimately damage our relationship.
Finally, she opened up one day. She explained how my constant career advice, though thoughtful, only made her feel inadequate and defensive. It took away her own sense of direction and choice. What I came to understand is that while I wanted to guide her to happiness, only she could define what that meant for herself. The best way I could support was not by telling her what to do, but by listening without judgement - providing a safe space for her to talk through her own goals and options as she figured things out.
This realization has stuck with me since in many aspects of my relationships. I now catch myself when the urge arises to offer direction or correction, and pause first to consider if it's my place. I understand that even if I can see someone is struggling or heading down a path I wouldn't choose, they have to walk their own journey. I remind myself how I would feel if roles were reversed and they were constantly analyzing my life choices. More often now I opt for asking thoughtful questions over giving prescriptive advice. My friends seem more willing to open up, and our connections feel less one-sided.
Just last month my friend was distraught over troubles in her new relationship. My instinct was to tell her all the reasons I thought the guy was no good and why she should end it. But instead, I bit my tongue and asked about what initially drew her to him and what they both valued in the relationship. By giving her space to air feelings without judgement, she was able to see the situation more objectively and realize on her own that they needed different things. She felt empowered in her decision to eventually break up with him, rather than being persuaded to action by my opinions.
Learning when to stand back and not tell others what to do has been a valuable life lesson for me. It has deepened my relationships and made me a better friend. I now understand that no one has all the answers for someone else’s life. The best way I can support loved ones is not by pushing them in the direction I deem best, but by walking alongside them with patience and understanding as they chart their own path forward. My role is not director of their journey - it is companion.
This is my response to the question from Thinkerscorner
This is a very satisfactory approach and it shows that even when people come to seek advice, they don't want advice. What they want is to express themselves and find answers on their own. It feels like when things take that course, it becomes easier for them to act on what they have concluded.
However, when you tell them what to do and what not to do, they get defensive and some even see you as someone who's trying to meddle in their affair.
There is a great lesson to learn from your post. Well Done 👍.
That is exactly the point. So it is better to allow they figure things out on their own sometimes.
You’ve said it all. It good to know where you belong or stand in other peoples lives. Like you said you’re a companion and not a director. I’m glad I came across your blog post. I’ve learnt a big thing from it.
I am glad you learned something. Thanks for coming around sis. :)
A nice approach you've taken courtesy of your sister. While you were trying to coach her, she helped you find a nicer approach to things, which is wonderful.
You did well.